Schedule Appointment »
702-660-7000
702-660-7000
A fresh wave of statistics has rolled in regarding 401(k) balances across America. At first glance, the numbers may seem impressive – Vanguard reports that the average balance of defined contribution plans, primarily 401(k)s, reached $134,128 in 2023. This marks a 19% increase from the end of 2022. Before we celebrate this apparent financial victory, it’s important to dig deeper and understand what these figures truly represent.
The reality is that averages can be misleading. They’re easily skewed by outliers, particularly those rare individuals who have managed to accumulate seven-figure balances in their 401(k)s. While these millionaire savers certainly exist, they are the exception rather than the rule. To gain a more accurate picture of how most Americans are faring with their retirement savings, we need to look at the median balances instead.
When we examine the median 401(k) balances by age group, a sobering truth emerges:
Under 25: $2,816
25 to 34: $14,933
35 to 44: $35,537
45 to 54: $60,763
55 to 64: $87,571
65 and older: $88,488
These numbers paint a very different picture than the rosy average of $134,128. They reveal that half of all 401(k) participants have less – often far less – than that amount saved for their retirement years.
Now, before panic sets in, it’s important to remember that these figures represent just one piece of the retirement savings puzzle. Many individuals have additional savings in other vehicles such as Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs), taxable brokerage accounts, or even real estate investments. However, for a significant portion of the American workforce, the 401(k) remains the primary – and sometimes only – retirement savings tool.
This reliance on 401(k)s as the be-all and end-all of retirement planning is concerning. While these employer-sponsored plans can certainly play a valuable role in building a nest egg, they shouldn’t be viewed as the sole solution to our long-term financial needs.
So why have 401(k)s become so dominant in the retirement landscape? The answer lies partly in their convenience. These plans are often automatically set up by employers, with contributions deducted directly from paychecks. Many companies also offer matching contributions, which can feel like “free money” to employees. Furthermore, the tax advantages of 401(k)s – particularly the ability to contribute pre-tax dollars – make them an attractive option for reducing current tax burdens.
However, this convenience and these immediate benefits can blind us to some of the limitations and potential drawbacks of relying too heavily on 401(k)s. Let’s explore a few reasons why diversifying beyond your 401(k) might be a wise move:
1. Limited Investment Options
Most 401(k) plans offer a restricted menu of investment choices, typically consisting of a handful of mutual funds. While this simplifies decision-making for participants, it also limits their ability to tailor their portfolio to their specific needs and risk tolerance. By exploring options outside of your 401(k), you can access a wider range of investments, including individual stocks, bonds, real estate investment trusts (REITs), and more.
2. Lack of Flexibility
401(k)s are designed for long-term saving, with strict rules governing when and how you can access your money. While this can be beneficial in preventing early withdrawals, it can also be problematic if you need to access funds before retirement age. Other investment vehicles, such as taxable brokerage accounts, offer more flexibility in terms of withdrawals.
3. Potential for High Fees
Many 401(k) plans come with administrative fees and expense ratios that can eat into your returns over time. While some plans offer low-cost options, others may saddle participants with high-fee funds that underperform the market. By investing outside of your 401(k), you have more control over the fees you pay.
4. Tax Considerations
While the ability to contribute pre-tax dollars to a traditional 401(k) can provide immediate tax benefits, it also means you’ll owe taxes on withdrawals in retirement. Depending on your tax situation in retirement, this could result in a higher tax burden than you anticipated. Diversifying with after-tax investment options, such as Roth IRAs or taxable accounts, can provide more tax flexibility in retirement.
5. Limited Control
With a 401(k), your investment options are largely determined by your employer and the plan administrator. You have little say in which funds are offered or how the plan is managed. By investing outside of your 401(k), you can take a more active role in managing your retirement savings.
 | Financial Decision Making 16-page Slide Deck If you do some of the right things financially, but do them in the wrong order, your finances will suffer. This quick guide gives you 4 easy steps in order of priority. |
So, what alternatives should we consider alongside our 401(k)s? Here are a few options to explore:
1. Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs)
Both traditional and Roth IRAs offer tax advantages and a wider range of investment options than most 401(k)s. A Roth IRA, in particular, can be an excellent complement to a traditional 401(k), as it provides tax diversity in retirement.
2. Taxable Brokerage Accounts
While these accounts don’t offer the same tax advantages as retirement accounts, they provide maximum flexibility in terms of investment choices and withdrawals. They can be an excellent option for goals that may occur before retirement age.
3. Real Estate Investments
Whether through direct property ownership or REITs, real estate can provide diversification and potential income streams that aren’t correlated with the stock market.
4. Health Savings Accounts (HSAs)
If you’re eligible, an HSA can serve as a powerful retirement savings tool. Contributions are tax-deductible, grow tax-free, and can be withdrawn tax-free for qualified medical expenses. After age 65, you can withdraw funds for any purpose without penalty (though non-medical withdrawals will be taxed as income).
5. Small Business Retirement Plans
For self-employed individuals or small business owners, options like SEP IRAs or Solo 401(k)s can offer higher contribution limits and more control than traditional employer-sponsored plans.
As we explore alternatives to the traditional 401(k), it’s worth considering a financial instrument that has stood the test of time: whole life insurance. While often overlooked in modern financial planning discussions, whole life insurance offers a unique combination of benefits that can complement and enhance your retirement strategy.
At its core, whole life insurance provides a death benefit to your beneficiaries, offering peace of mind and financial protection for your loved ones. However, its value extends far beyond this primary function. Unlike term life insurance, which expires after a set period, whole life insurance accumulates cash value over time, creating a financial asset you can leverage during your lifetime.
This cash value grows tax-deferred and can be accessed through policy loans without triggering taxable events. This feature provides a level of flexibility rarely found in other financial instruments. Whether you need funds for a major purchase, want to supplement your retirement income, or face unexpected expenses, your whole life insurance policy can serve as a readily available source of liquidity.
The growth of cash value in a well-designed whole life policy is guaranteed, offering a level of certainty that can be comforting in an uncertain financial landscape. This guaranteed growth occurs independently of market fluctuations, providing a stable counterbalance to more volatile investments in your portfolio.
Many whole life insurance policies also offer the potential for dividends. While not guaranteed, dividends from mutual insurance companies have historically provided policyholders with additional value, further boosting the policy’s cash value or providing a source of income.
For business owners, whole life insurance can be a valuable tool for succession planning, key person insurance, or funding buy-sell agreements. The flexibility and tax advantages of these policies make them adaptable to various business needs.
It’s important to note that not all whole life insurance policies are created equal. The benefits you receive depend greatly on how the policy is structured. Working with a knowledgeable professional who can design a policy tailored to your specific needs and financial goals is crucial.
While whole life insurance shouldn’t be viewed as a replacement for other retirement savings vehicles, it can serve as a powerful complement to your overall financial strategy. Its unique combination of guaranteed growth, tax advantages, and lifetime coverage makes it worth considering as part of a diversified approach to long-term financial planning.
As we reflect on the latest 401(k) balance figures, let’s resist the temptation to judge our financial health solely by these metrics. Instead, let’s broaden our perspective and consider a more holistic approach to retirement planning. By diversifying our savings and investment strategies, we can build a more resilient and personalized financial future.
Remember, the path to a secure retirement isn’t about blindly following averages or relying on a single savings vehicle. It’s about understanding our unique needs, goals, and circumstances, and crafting a strategy that aligns with our individual vision for the future. While 401(k)s can certainly play a role in this strategy, they shouldn’t be the only tool in our retirement planning toolbox.
As we navigate the complex world of personal finance, let’s strive to educate ourselves, seek out diverse perspectives, and make informed decisions that serve our long-term interests. By taking a more active and comprehensive approach to our financial planning, we can work towards a retirement that’s not just financially secure, but truly fulfilling.
In the end, our financial future is too important to leave to chance or to entrust entirely to a single savings vehicle. Let’s take control of our destiny, explore all our options, and build a retirement strategy that’s as unique and multifaceted as we are. After all, isn’t that what true financial independence is all about?
by Gracine McFie
There are many ways to access information about finances, but it can be hard to determine which sources are trustworthy. I like to put information together in an accurate, straightforward, easy to understand manner so people can make good financial decisions based on the information provided without having to waste time wondering if the source is reliable.
