Schedule Appointment »
317-912-1000
317-912-1000
Joseph Conrad, the Polish-British novelist, once observed, “A man is best judged by the quality of his enemies.” This statement might sound counterintuitive at first glance, but when carefully considered, its profound logic emerges. In personal and professional realms, the caliber of those who oppose us often reveals more about our character, values, and impact than the praise of our supporters.
Consider your preferred sports figure, political leader, or religious icon. Your passion for them likely intensifies when respected individuals critique them. The more distinguished the critic, the more their opposition seems to validate the importance of the person they criticize. We rarely pay attention to criticism from someone of little consequence. When a respected figure offers analysis or scrutiny, it lends credibility to the subject of their criticism.
This phenomenon operates across many domains. A championship athlete criticized by another champion garners more respect than one criticized by a benchwarmer. A political leader opposed by formidable, intelligent opponents commands more attention than one dismissed by inconsequential figures. In business, companies that disrupt industries face criticism from established industry leaders—criticism that ultimately validates their innovative approaches.
The source of criticism should always be carefully considered. Is the criticism coming from individuals you admire, wish to emulate, or hope to pattern your life after? If not, perhaps it doesn’t merit concern. When criticism comes from those you love, who love you, or whom you respect, it deserves thorough consideration. Such feedback often contains valuable insights that can lead to personal and professional growth.
While all people may be created equal in their inherent worth, not all criticism deserves equal weight. The ancient Greek painter Apelles understood this principle. Legend has it that he would hide behind a curtain to hear unfiltered comments about his latest works. Once, a shoemaker correctly pointed out an error in how Apelles had depicted a shoe in one of his paintings. Apelles appreciated this feedback and made the correction. When the shoemaker began critiquing other aspects of the painting beyond his expertise, Apelles famously responded, “Shoemaker, stick to your last.” This phrase, which has survived millennia, reminds us that the value of criticism is relative to the expertise of the critic.
How we respond to criticism can either strengthen or weaken us. Dismissive feedback from those without relevant experience or skill should not diminish our resolve. However, criticism from successful individuals in our field of interest deserves careful attention. These critiques can expand our perspectives, toughen our resilience, and sharpen our skills, helping us become better at what we do.
This principle applies across disciplines—from arts to business to personal development. During my time in chiropractic school, a local chiropractor appeared on Dr. Dean Edell’s medical show and faced harsh criticism. Rather than harming his practice, this criticism from a respected medical voice increased his patient numbers dramatically. The quality of his “enemy” enhanced his credibility.
At McFie Insurance, we encounter criticism regarding whole life insurance. Some critiques provide valuable perspectives that help us refine our thinking and recommendations. Others, particularly those from critics without deep understanding of how these policies can be strategically utilized, we let slide “like water off a duck’s back.”
The Dutch folk tale of “The Man, the Boy, and the Donkey” offers an instructive parallel. In this story, a man and his son travel to market with their donkey. Along the way, they face criticism regardless of their choices: when the man rides the donkey, when the boy rides, when they both ride, and even when they carry the donkey to avoid riding it altogether. The moral becomes clear: “If you try to please everyone, you end up pleasing nobody.”
Many financial experts criticize whole life insurance policies, often claiming they offer poor returns compared to other investment vehicles. These criticisms focus on the early years of a policy when cash values grow slowly, or on comparing whole life insurance to investments without accounting for the additional benefits and guarantees that whole life insurance provides.
Despite vocal critics, we at McFie Insurance have witnessed firsthand how whole life insurance has benefited hundreds of clients. Our confidence grows with each critique because we understand the practical applications of these policies beyond theoretical discussions.
One of the most valuable concepts we teach is leveraging whole life insurance cash value to recover capital expenditures. This approach allows policyholders to maintain control of their money while funding major purchases or investments. As Mark Twain observed, “It is easier to fool someone than to convince them they have been fooled.” Many people have been led to believe that whole life insurance is a poor financial tool, yet they fail to recognize how it can create liquidity, provide guaranteed growth, and offer tax advantages while protecting their families.
Nelson Nash, the creator of the Infinite Banking Concept, discovered this power when he refinanced his real estate investments using policy loans instead of bank financing. The strategy allowed him to recover capital costs while maintaining control of his money. In our practice, we’ve helped clients recover capital costs on everything from college tuition to business expansions, from real estate investments to credit card debt consolidation.
When examining whole life insurance objectively, several features emerge that critics overlook:
Guaranteed Cash Value Growth: Unlike many financial products, participating whole life insurance policies offer guaranteed cash value growth. Each premium payment contributes to building equity in the policy, which becomes accessible through policy loans without credit checks or application processes.
Death Benefit Protection: Beyond cash value, these policies provide a guaranteed death benefit that helps families maintain financial stability after losing a loved one. This protection lasts for the insured’s entire lifetime, as long as premiums are paid.
Dividend Potential: Participating whole life policies from mutual insurance companies may pay dividends when the company performs well. While not guaranteed, many established insurance companies have consistently paid dividends for over a century.
Tax Advantages: Cash value growth in whole life insurance is tax-deferred, and death benefits are generally income-tax-free. When structured properly, policy loans can provide tax-free access to cash value.
Protection from Creditors: In many states, life insurance cash values and death benefits receive protection from creditors, making them valuable assets during financial hardship.
Not all whole life insurance policies are created equal. A well-designed policy for wealth building prioritizes cash value growth over maximum death benefit. These policies usually include paid-up additions riders that allow for accelerated cash value accumulation.
Critics point to poorly designed policies with high agent commissions and low cash value as evidence against whole life insurance. This criticism addresses implementation rather than the main concept. A properly structured policy from a reputable mutual insurance company can be a powerful financial tool when used correctly.
Think about a business owner who needs capital for expansion. Traditional financing might require extensive paperwork, credit checks, and collateral arrangements. With enough cash value in a whole life policy, the business owner can access funds within days by taking a policy loan. The loan carries no requirements for immediate repayment—interest can be paid annually, and principal repayment can follow whatever schedule works for the business.
For families funding college education, policy loans can provide liquidity without affecting financial aid eligibility in the way that liquidating investments might. After graduation, parents can establish a repayment schedule that works for their budget, rather than adhering to terms set by a third-party lender.
Homeowners can use policy loans for down payments, renovations, or even to purchase investment properties. The flexibility of repayment allows them to manage cash flow effectively while still earning dividends on their policy’s full value.
Critics of whole life insurance often focus exclusively on rate of return, comparing insurance policies to investment vehicles like mutual funds or ETFs. This comparison misses vital aspects of financial planning: risk management, liquidity needs, and the recovery of capital.
As we often explain to clients, it’s not just the rate of return on your money that matters—it’s also the return OF your money. Many investments with promising returns come with significant risks and limited liquidity. Whole life insurance provides a foundation of guaranteed growth and accessibility that complements other, higher-return investments in a comprehensive financial strategy.
The recovery of capital concept involves recapturing the opportunity cost of major purchases. When you buy a car with cash, for example, you lose the capital and all the growth that capital could have generated over time. By instead taking a policy loan and repaying it on your schedule, you maintain control of your capital while still acquiring the vehicle you need.
Financial advisors who criticize whole life insurance often have valid concerns about poorly designed policies, excessive premiums, or mismatched client needs. These critiques provide valuable perspective. Many critics have inherent biases:
Understanding these biases helps contextualize criticism and identify which feedback merits attention.
The most valuable critics of whole life insurance are those who understand its mechanics and legitimate applications but can point out specific weaknesses in implementation or strategy. Their critiques help refine approaches and identify situations where other financial tools might better serve client needs.
When financial professionals with extensive experience and no competing interests raise concerns about whole life insurance in specific scenarios, their feedback deserves careful consideration. These perspectives lead to improved policy designs and more nuanced client recommendations.
For individuals considering whole life insurance, the volume of conflicting information can be overwhelming. A few principles can help navigate these waters:
By approaching whole life insurance with a thorough understanding, consumers can benefit from its unique features while avoiding the pitfalls that critics rightfully identify.
At McFie Insurance, our confidence in recommending appropriately designed whole life insurance grows stronger with each informed critique. Like the chiropractor whose practice flourished after public criticism from a respected doctor, we find validation in the quality of our opponents.
We understand that whole life insurance isn’t appropriate for everyone. Some situations call for term insurance only, while others require no life insurance at all. For those seeking a financial tool that combines protection, guaranteed growth, tax advantages, and flexible liquidity, properly structured whole life insurance deserves consideration despite its critics.
Conrad’s observation about being judged by the quality of our enemies reminds us to evaluate criticism based on its source and substance. The most consequential critics are those with expertise, experience, and thoughtful analysis. Their challenges strengthen our resolve and refine our approach.
For those interested in exploring how whole life insurance might serve as a foundation for recovering capital costs and building sustainable wealth, we invite you to schedule a consultation with us. Beyond the polarized debate about whole life insurance, individual circumstances determine its appropriateness and value. As financial strategies become increasingly personalized, the wisdom to distinguish helpful criticism from noise becomes even more essential.
Tomas P. McFie DC PhD
Tom McFie is the founder of McFie Insurance and co-host of the WealthTalks podcast which helps people keep more of the money they make, so they can have financial peace of mind. He has reviewed 1000s of whole life insurance policies and has practiced the Infinite Banking Concept for nearly 20 years, making him one of the foremost experts on achieving financial peace of mind. His latest book, A Biblical Guide to Personal Finance, can be purchased here.
This free binder has the information to build your own Infinite Banking system.
