Schedule Appointment »
317-912-1000
317-912-1000
When you begin exploring whole life insurance as a financial tool, one of the most common points of question centers around the relationship between cash value and death benefit. Many people mistakenly believe these are two separate buckets of money, when in reality, they are two different aspects of the same asset. Understanding this distinction is essential for anyone considering using whole life insurance for infinite banking.
The cash value in a whole life insurance policy represents your equity in the death benefit. Think of it like equity in your home. When you own a house worth $500,000 and you have paid down $200,000 of the mortgage, you don’t own two separate assets. You own one asset (the house) with $200,000 of equity in it. The same principle applies to whole life insurance.
Your cash value is the portion of the death benefit that is no longer at risk for the insurance company. It is the paid-up insurance you have established in your policy. As you pay premiums over time, you are building equity in your death benefit through this paid-up insurance component.
This is an important distinction because it means when you pass away, your beneficiaries receive the death benefit, not the death benefit plus the cash value. The cash value has always been part of the death benefit. At some point in the future (usually at age 100 or 121), all whole life policies will mature, which means the cash value will equal the death benefit. At this time, you would own the entire death benefit.
Confusion often arises when insurance agents compare universal life insurance to whole life insurance. Some agents will point out that with certain universal life policies, your heirs can receive both the cash value and the death benefit. This sounds appealing at first, but the comparison reveals a misunderstanding of how these two types of policies work.
Cash value in a universal life insurance policy (particularly Option B policies) consists of premium dollars above and beyond the cost of the death benefit, which is “rented” with one-year term insurance. This cash value might earn an interest rate or be invested by the insurance company, depending on the type of universal life policy. The idea is to always have a reserve from which to pay the cost of the death benefit as long as possible.
Since you are always “renting” the death benefit in this type of universal life policy, of course you should expect your family to receive the death benefit plus any cash value you had accumulated to pay for future insurance costs which had not yet been incurred. It is not a better deal, it is simply a different structure.
In contrast, cash value in a whole life policy is different. It represents your equity in a permanent death benefit, not a side fund to pay for future term insurance. The insurance company will write your family a check for the entire death benefit when you pass away, not just the cash value.
Understanding that cash value is equity in your death benefit helps explain why insurance companies are willing to make policy loans to you based on your cash value. The insurance company lends you money from their general fund, using your policy values as collateral. Since cash value represents your equity in the death benefit, the insurance company isn’t at risk by making you a loan up to the amount of your cash value.
Think about it this way: If you have $100,000 of cash value in a policy with a $300,000 death benefit, the insurance company knows that even if you never repay the loan and pass away tomorrow, they only have to pay out $200,000 (the death benefit minus the loan balance). Your cash value serves as their security.
This is why the compounding growth of your policy isn’t affected when you take a policy loan. The insurance company is investing in you by extending credit, and it is one of their safest investments because if you don’t pay back the loan, they will deduct it from your death benefit when the time comes.
The amount you can borrow from your life insurance policy for infinite banking purposes is tied to your cash value. Insurance companies will usually allow you to borrow up to 90-95% of your current cash value, though the percentage can vary by company and policy.
Several factors influence how much cash value you have available to borrow against:
Policy Design: The way your policy is structured plays a role in how quickly cash value accumulates. Policies designed for infinite banking will minimize the base death benefit and maximize the paid-up additions rider. This design approach builds cash value more efficiently than a policy with base premiums alone. The sooner paid-up insurance is established in a policy, the faster the cash value will accrue.
Premium Amount and Payment Schedule: Larger premium payments build cash value faster. However, there are limits to consider. Keeping the growth of paid-up insurance within the guidelines of the Internal Revenue Code’s seven-pay period will keep the policy from becoming a Modified Endowment Contract, which could create a tax liability when you take policy loans.
Time: Whole life insurance is a long-term financial tool. In the early years of the policy, a larger portion of your premium goes toward establishing the death benefit. As the policy matures, more of your premium contributes to building cash value. This is why people who start policies later in life have less growth to expect compared to younger individuals who can take advantage of decades of compounding.
Dividends: Participating whole life insurance policies from mutual insurance companies pay dividends when the insurance company is profitable. When these dividends are used to purchase additional paid-up insurance, they accelerate cash value growth. Over time, this dividend-purchased insurance can become a large portion of your cash value.
Policy Loans Outstanding: When you have an outstanding policy loan, the loan balance is deducted from your available cash value for borrowing purposes. If you have $100,000 of cash value but $30,000 in outstanding loans, you would have $70,000 available to borrow (less the small percentage that insurance companies hold in reserve).
There is always a cost of interest with any loan including policy loans. Some proponents of infinite banking argue that you “recover all the interest” you pay the insurance company. This can be true in a limited sense, but it is important to understand the dynamics at work.
The loan rate can be variable or fixed, and interest on policy loans is simple interest for the year – compounding annually if you have the policy loan outstanding for more than a year. Many insurance companies quote interest in advance, meaning if you take a loan for $10,000 at 5% in advance at the beginning of the policy year, the insurance company will reserve $500 of interest on the loan upfront. If you paid the loan off after six months, they would credit back $250 of the interest to your policy.
What happens to your policy when you have a loan outstanding depends on whether your policy is a direct recognition or non-direct recognition policy. With non-direct recognition policies, your entire cash value continues to earn the same dividend rate regardless of loans. With direct recognition policies, the portion of cash value securing the loan may earn a different rate.
It is not accurate to consider that there is a net gain by taking a policy loan because the insurance company’s dividend rate might be 6% while the policy loan rate is 5%. There is a net cost to policy loan interest, and this cost is only “recovered” over time and to the extent a policy loan isn’t outstanding.
Understanding what determines your borrowing capacity helps you make strategic decisions about when and how to use policy loans. Here are some considerations:
Purpose of the Loan: For business or investment purposes, policy loan interest may be tax deductible as an investment interest expense if you are itemizing your deductions rather than taking the standard deduction. This effectively lowers the cost of borrowing. You will need to keep documentation tracing the funds from the source of the policy loan to the ultimate use of the money to justify this deduction.
Duration of the Loan: If you plan to have a policy loan outstanding longer than 5-10 years, it is best to run the numbers and make sure this is the best strategy for your plans. People who start a policy later in life have less growth to expect in the policy, so it makes sense to have policy loans outstanding for shorter periods than someone younger who is buying insurance at better rates.
Loan Repayment Strategy: You have complete control over how and when you repay policy loans. Some people choose to make regular payments (like a traditional loan), while others may make irregular payments based on cash flow. The flexibility is one of the advantages of policy loans, but it requires discipline to ensure you are not eroding the long-term value of your policy.
Balance and Efficiency: Too much of a good thing can become problematic. If you fund a policy with the maximum amount available and then borrow everything out for a long-term investment, the efficiency of the strategy diminishes. Balance is key. Sometimes it makes more sense to start a smaller policy with part of your funds while you make an investment, then use the income from that investment to fund ongoing premiums or start additional policies.
One of the best benefits for people using the infinite banking concept is having liquid money that is still earning a return, yet remaining accessible for opportunities as they arise. When money sits in a low-interest savings account earning 0.5% annually, waiting for the right investment or business opportunity, this represents a lost opportunity.
By keeping money in a whole life policy instead, you can minimize this “cash drag” while maintaining liquidity. Your money is earning a stronger return (long-term) than it would in a savings account, but it remains accessible through policy loans whenever you need it. You can make money both from your investments when they come along and while your money is waiting for good opportunities. You don’t work any harder, but the results are better.
The death benefit of your policy should not be overlooked either. A strong permanent death benefit provides better options for passive income in retirement compared to buying term insurance that you will likely need to let expire in your 60s or 70s. A permanent death benefit ensures your strategies can continue and provides financial security for your family regardless of when you pass away.
At the end of the day, understanding the relationship between cash value and death benefit helps you make better decisions about policy design, borrowing strategies, and long-term financial planning. Cash value isn’t separate from the death benefit. Rather, it shows your growing equity in a permanent asset that can serve you throughout your lifetime while providing security for your loved ones.
When you borrow against this equity, you aren’t spending your money. You’re accessing the insurance company’s money while your policy continues to grow. This is the essence of infinite banking: using permanent life insurance as a financial tool that works for you in multiple ways at once.
The key is to work with professionals who understand how to properly design policies for maximum cash value accumulation, who can help you determine appropriate funding levels, and who will educate you on the best strategies for using policy loans effectively. With the right foundation and understanding, whole life insurance can become one of the most versatile and reliable tools in your financial toolkit.
Tomas P. McFie DC PhD
Tom McFie is the founder of McFie Insurance and co-host of the WealthTalks podcast which helps people keep more of the money they make, so they can have financial peace of mind. He has reviewed 1000s of whole life insurance policies and has practiced the Infinite Banking Concept for nearly 20 years, making him one of the foremost experts on achieving financial peace of mind. His latest book, A Biblical Guide to Personal Finance, can be purchased here.
This free binder has the information to build your own Infinite Banking system.
