Schedule Appointment »
317-912-1000
317-912-1000
When Thomas Jefferson drafted the Declaration of Independence, he deliberately chose the phrase “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness” rather than John Locke’s original formulation of “life, liberty, and property.” This change came at the suggestion of Benjamin Franklin, who recognized that while property could be bought, sold, or taken away, the right to pursue happiness was truly inalienable. The Founding Fathers understood that ownership and property remained essential components in the pursuit of happiness.
This historical context provides an important foundation for understanding the relationship between life insurance and the pursuit of happiness. Life insurance represents a unique form of property that can contribute to one’s financial security and peace of mind, thereby supporting the pursuit of happiness for policyholders and their beneficiaries.
In 1911, the U.S. Supreme Court established in the landmark case of Grigsby v. Russell that life insurance is legally classified as property, not merely an investment. This distinction is crucial for understanding the nature and value of life insurance. Unlike investments, which may or may not appreciate (depending on market conditions), properly structured life insurance policies provide guaranteed benefits and represent tangible assets that can be sold, transferred, or leveraged like other forms of property.
Many people today incorrectly refer to life insurance as an investment. The Cambridge Dictionary defines an investment as “the act of putting money, effort, time, etc. into something to make a profit, get an advantage, or the money, effort, time, etc. used to do this.” While investments may eventually become assets or property, they can also become liabilities or expenditures that never mature into assets.
This mischaracterization as an investment rather than property has led to confusion about the purpose and value of life insurance. It has also opened the door for insurance products that emphasize investment-like qualities over the core function of providing financial protection.
Over time, insurance companies have introduced various products that blur the line between insurance and investment. Universal Life Insurance products, including traditional Universal Life, Indexed Universal Life, and Variable Universal Life, shift responsibility for overcoming the cost of insurance from the company to the policyholder.
With these products, as the insured ages, the cost of insurance increases, requiring higher premiums over time. To maintain coverage, policyholders must earn sufficient returns through variable market interest rates, stock index returns, or portfolio performance. This dependence on investment returns undermines the purpose of life insurance: to provide guaranteed financial protection for beneficiaries upon the death of the insured.
The introduction of these hybrid products means that Term Life and traditional Whole Life insurance remain the only life insurance products that maintain the property or asset qualities recognized by the Supreme Court in Grigsby v. Russell. These products provide certainty and guarantees that investment-oriented insurance products can’t match.
Life insurance has one main purpose: to replace the earnings of the insured upon their death. When life insurance is tied to variable interest rates or market returns, it can no longer guarantee this replacement function. Universal Life insurance policies allow companies to increase premium costs when investment returns fail to cover the rising cost of insurance, which has led to numerous class-action lawsuits over premium increases.
This problem isn’t necessarily the fault of insurance companies. These products exist because consumers hope to achieve higher investment returns without fully accepting the associated risks. Greed often blinds people to the trade-offs involved.
Dividend-paying Whole Life insurance and Term insurance policies provide a guaranteed death benefit. The difference between Whole Life and Term is that Term insurance offers this guarantee for a specified period, while Whole Life insurance guarantees the death benefit for the insured’s entire lifetime.
Whole Life insurance can provide this lifetime guarantee because each premium payment converts a portion of the death benefit into “paid-up insurance.” This paid-up insurance becomes an asset or property the policyholder can sell or leverage like any other asset.
The right to own assets and property is vital to the pursuit of happiness, as recognized by America’s founders and upheld by the Supreme Court. Dividend-paying Whole Life insurance embodies this principle by providing a guaranteed asset that supports financial security and peace of mind.
Dietrich Bonhoeffer, the World War II martyr, observed that “happiness depends so little on circumstances and so much more on what we do with our circumstances.” Research indicates that lasting happiness comes from engaging in activities that promote well-being. This principle applies to financial matters as well – consistency and persistence in managing one’s assets, including life insurance, can lead to greater financial security and peace of mind.
Many people mistakenly believe that purchasing dividend-paying Whole Life insurance will automatically make them happier and wealthier. However, realizing the full benefits requires persistent and consistent management of the paid-up insurance that develops within the policy over time.
When managed diligently, dividend-paying Whole Life insurance can become an extraordinary asset that provides financial security beyond what many hope to achieve through conventional investments. This is not because it functions as an investment, but because it represents a stable, guaranteed financial asset that can enhance investment strategies and support overall financial well-being.
Term life insurance provides coverage for a specific period, typically 5, 10, 15, 20, or 30 years. It offers a death benefit if the insured dies during the term but after the term expires the inexpensive premiums of the term become much more expensive. Term insurance doesn’t build cash value, which means there’s no way to recover the cost of insurance over time.
The advantage of term insurance is its initial affordability. During the term period, premiums are lower than for other types of life insurance. This makes it accessible for young families and those with limited budgets who need coverage.
Universal Life insurance was introduced in the 1980s as a more flexible alternative to Whole Life. Despite being classified as permanent life insurance, it often fails to provide permanent coverage.
All Universal Life products are built on one-year renewable term insurance, meaning the cost of insurance increases annually as the insured ages. Premiums in excess of the cost of insurance accumulate as cash value, which can be used to pay future premiums or grow via interest or investment returns.
Universal Life policies offer flexible premiums and death benefits, but this flexibility comes with risks. If cash value growth is insufficient to cover the rising cost of insurance, policyholders may need to pay higher premiums than originally projected to maintain coverage. In many cases, guaranteed cash values eventually decline to zero, making Universal Life an unreliable source for permanent protection.
Whole Life insurance provides coverage for the insured’s entire lifetime and includes a guaranteed death benefit and cash value component. Unlike Universal Life, Whole Life features fixed premiums that never increase, providing certainty and predictability for long-term planning.
The cash value in a Whole Life policy represents the policyholder’s equity in the death benefit. This cash value is accessible through policy loans or withdrawals, providing a source of liquidity for various financial needs including education funding, debt repayment, business expenses, and retirement planning.
With well-designed policies, the guaranteed cash value can exceed total premiums paid within 8-15 years. Participating Whole Life policies also may pay dividends, which can be used to purchase additional paid-up insurance, enhancing the death benefit and cash value growth.
While Whole Life premiums are initially higher than term insurance premiums, they remain level for life. For people who want permanent coverage and cash value accumulation with their insurance, whole life insurance is the answer.
Not all life insurance policies are created equal, and proper design is crucial for maximizing benefits. For Whole Life insurance, policy design impacts cash value accumulation, premium efficiency, and overall performance.
A well-designed Whole Life policy typically includes:
Poor policy design can result in slow cash value growth, inappropriate death benefit protection, and tax complications. Working with knowledgeable professionals who understand how to design policies for peak performance is essential.
One of the most powerful features of Whole Life insurance is the ability to access cash value through policy loans while the policy continues to grow. This unique feature allows policyholders to use their money for various purposes while maintaining the growth of their policy.
Policy loans must be managed responsibly, however. The insurance company charges interest on policy loans. If left unpaid this interest gets added to your loan balance. Interest for the next year is then charged on the new, larger balance.
Policy loan interest may be tax-deductible when the loan is used for business or investment purposes, enhancing the efficiency of this strategy.
Effective management of policy loans involves:
Life insurance, particularly dividend-paying Whole Life insurance, can serve as a cornerstone for a comprehensive financial strategy. Rather than viewing it in isolation or as an alternative to other financial tools, consider how it complements other elements of your financial plan.
Whole Life insurance provides a stable, guaranteed component that can balance more volatile investments. The cash value component offers liquidity that can be used for emergencies, opportunities and every day needs without disrupting other investments. The death benefit also provides protection for loved ones and can facilitate wealth transfer across generations.
When integrated well, whole life insurance enhances financial security and flexibility while supporting long-term wealth accumulation and preservation.
The pursuit of happiness, as enshrined in the Declaration of Independence, encompasses financial security and well-being. Life insurance, better understood as property rather than investment, plays a vital role in this pursuit by providing guarantees, protection, and financial stability.
By recognizing the true nature of life insurance as an asset and managing it consistently and diligently, individuals can enhance their financial security and peace of mind. This, in turn, supports the broader pursuit of happiness for themselves and their loved ones.
Dividend-paying Whole Life insurance embodies the principles of ownership and asset building that are fundamental to financial independence and security. When properly designed and managed, it becomes an active tool for building and preserving wealth across generations.
In the end, life insurance is not about getting rich quick or beating the market. It’s about creating certainty in an uncertain world, providing protection for loved ones, and establishing a financial foundation that supports the pursuit of happiness throughout life and beyond.
by Anna McFie
With so much important information to learn and understand about managing money, it's helpful to have content that is clear and straightforward to understand. Whether it’s video, article or print resources, designing information in a way that’s clear and straightforward for you to understand is my goal so you can have great success with managing your money well.
This free binder has the information to build your own Infinite Banking system.
